askaudubon.online

Birdwatching with John James Audubon

Plate 232 – Hooded Merganser

Hooded merganser

Plate 232 of the first edition of "Birds of America" by John James Audubon.

Alexander Wilson (1766-1813) and John James Audubon went on one known bird walk together. When discussion came around to the Hooded merganser, Audubon commented, “The Hooded Merganser was not uncommon in the neighbourhood of Louisville during summer, and I told Wilson so.” Hooded mergansers today around Louisville are uncommon any time of the year. The largest number in the neighborhood of Louisville today will likely be found not during the summer but during the winter swimming on ponds managed by the Louisville Water Company (see eBird Checklist S41064962). What was disputed was the color of the chicks. Audubon was adamant that the chicks of the Hooded merganser were “very dark brown.” The chicks were “not yellow, as is alleged by some writers.”

On August 23, 1813, Alexander Wilson died from malaria. Wilson had just completed the seventh of what turned out to be nine volumes of American Ornithology. Close to his side was Reverend John Bachman (see Plate 187) who had been assisting Wilson with completing the publication of American Ornithology. Bachman was saddened to see Wilson fall short of completing his work and see him die “by inches with poverty neglect & mortification.” Although George Ord (1781-1866) refused to let American Ornithology go unfinished and worked to complete the book to establish the name of Alexander Wilson as the “Father of American Ornithology” and make available one of the most important references for the birds of North America ever written.

Ord included in the ninth volume of American Ornithology the diary that Alexander Wilson kept. As it was in Birds of America and throughout the scientific community, “God as the Creator” was credited for the natural world and its many different species of plants and animals. Also to conform to the rules and requirements of the scientific community at the time, Ord divided the birds “into Clases [sic], Orders, Genera, Species, and Varieties; but in doing this, scarcely two have agreed on the same mode of arrangement, and this has indeed proved a source of great perplexity to the student.” The list that Wilson and Ord settled on was according to those as compiled by Dr. John Latham in General Synopsis of Birds (1781–1801) and Thomas Pennant in Arctic Zoology (1784-1785).

In 1815, Ord was accepted into the Academy of Natural Sciences and then became the vice-president of the Academy in 1816. Ord also took full advantage of these positions to disparage and to criticize John James Audubon to the degree that he came very close to foiling the publication of Birds of America.